The short story “The Cookie” was a very interesting read to
me. At first, I was confused by the format of the text, finding it very
difficult to read because of all the commas and sentence breaks. Then, I looked
past the structure and focused on the content of the passage. I was confused
how someone can completely misidentify or forget the taste of something. In
this case, when the woman took a sip of tea, she was reminded of a particular
taste, but she couldn’t pinpoint it. Then all of the sudden, she was reminded
of her Aunt Leonie’s madeleine cookies because it was her aunt who used to dip
the cookies into her tea. Ironically, I have had an experience very similar to
the one depicted in this passage. When I was about five or six living in
London, my Dad brought back a combination of desserts. Looking back, I had no
idea what the desserts are and my Dad couldn’t remember for the life of him
what I was talking about. So, the memory of another worldly dessert was all I had
to go on. Then one day, about three years ago, I ordered bread pudding for
dessert at Pamela’s Diner back home. Little did I know how shocked I was about
to be. I took a bite of the magnificent looking dessert and sure enough, the
memory of my Dad bringing home an assortment of desserts popped into my head.
That was what he brought home ten or so years ago. The decade long mystery was
finally solved similarly to the one in the passage “The Cookie.”
*Note: not a short story, but rather an excerpt from a longer work/series of novels, and the narrator is male.
ReplyDeleteGrade: Check minus (Good usage of personal anecdote to relate to the Proust reading, but part of the assignment was to incorporate quotations/excerpts from the reading.)